In the end, there was no clear winner — it was near impossible to compare them fairly due to the mistakes in the orders.
However, I did prefer Wendy’s meal I received over the one from Burger King. The burger was thicker, which I believe would have been even if the orders had been made correctly. I also found that the patty in the Bacon King was a touch dry compared to the Baconator.
I liked both nuggets pretty much equally, as well as the fries. However, when it came down to price, I felt that Wendy’s meal was a better deal — and if you’re looking for an extra patty, I hope you get lucky like me.