Thrift store returns 146-year-old marriage certificate to great-granddaughter

A US thrift store has managed to return a 146-year-old marriage certificate back to its owners’ descendant.

Staff at the Hope Chest Thrift Store in Bolivia, North Carolina, were able to track down the couple’s great-granddaughter Irene Cornish and gift her with a piece of her family’s history.

Pam Phelps, an employee at the shop, unearthed the document while she was cleaning an antique 1889 print of a young girl and a dog when she came across a document hidden in the back of the frame.

She soon discovered it was an 1865 New Jersey marriage certificate for a man named William and a woman named Katey.

Determined to reunite the document with its rightful inheritors, Phelps and her colleagues sparked a search for the couple’s living family members.

After the quest attracted TV coverage by local broadcaster WWAY-TV, people began to message Cornish about it on Ancestry.com, convinced that the couple William and Katey could be her great-grandparents, William and Katherine DeWorth.

“I haven’t been on Ancestry in quite a few months,” Cornish, who lives in upstate New York, told WWAY-TV. “I actually went on to research a family member on the other side. And I happened to notice I had these messages.”

She said she was unsure how the document ended up in a random thrift store in North Carolina but said some of her family’s things were donated to second-hand shops which could be a possible explanation.

“Sadly the Old Homestead, the person that inherited that in the family basically sold everything that was in it to a local thrift shop,” Cornish explained, “and ultimately lost the home.”

“My mother passed away five years ago,” Cornish added. “I don’t have any … immediate family in the area where I live. I feel a little isolated at times. So, it just felt comforting that, oh, these people are reaching out somehow. I am connected.”

She also said that she hopes to frame the certificate and donate it to a museum one day.

Tom Kucher

For as long as Tom can remember, he has understood the reality around him through the tinted glasses of works of fiction, be it books, films, TV shows, or anime. An English graduate, he wrote articles on a wide array of topics for several years, from entertainment and pop culture to history and literature. Before that, he was an educator and a roleplay game writer and developer. It is his deeply-rooted love for performing arts and visual media that led him to become a part of the DC team in 2020.

Share
Published by
Tom Kucher